MLB Game Preview: Pittsburgh Pirates (25-24) vs. St. Louis Cardinals (28-20)

0
28
St. Louis Cardinals logo

First Pitch: 7:45 PM ET / 6:45 PM CT

Venue: Busch Stadium — St. Louis, Missouri

Broadcast: SportsNet Pittsburgh / Bally Sports Midwest / MLB.TV

Venue Profile — Busch Stadium

  • Location: Downtown St. Louis
  • Capacity: ~45,500
  • Park Factor: Slightly pitcher‑friendly
  • Home Run Profile: Suppresses opposite‑field power; neutral to pull power
  • Run Environment: Moderate scoring, heavily influenced by humidity and wind

Busch Stadium rewards ground‑ball pitchers and contact‑oriented offenses, which plays into St. Louis’ strengths.

Weather Update (Forecast for First Pitch)

  • Temperature: 78–81°F
  • Wind: 6–9 mph blowing in from right‑center
  • Humidity: ~62%
  • Chance of Rain: <10%
  • Impact: Slight suppression of fly‑ball carry; advantage to pitchers

Injury Report

Pittsburgh Pirates

  • Oneil Cruz — Probable (ankle)
  • Ke’Bryan Hayes — Out (back)
  • Henry Davis — Questionable (hand)
  • David Bednar — Out (forearm)
  • Marco Gonzales — Out (elbow)

St. Louis Cardinals

  • Paul Goldschmidt — Probable (hamstring)
  • Nolan Arenado — Probable (wrist)
  • Tommy Edman — Out (shoulder)
  • Ryan Helsley — Out (lat strain)
  • Lars Nootbaar — Questionable (illness)

Impact:

  • Pittsburgh’s bullpen is weakened without Bednar, making late‑inning leads fragile.
  • St. Louis missing Edman hurts defensive versatility, but Goldschmidt and Arenado being active stabilizes the lineup.
  • Both teams enter with key players banged up, but St. Louis’ depth is stronger.

Team Records & Recent Form

Pittsburgh Pirates (25–24)

Last 10: 5–5 Road Record: 12–13 Run Differential: –4 Team Identity:

  • Young, aggressive lineup
  • Inconsistent starting pitching
  • Bullpen volatility without Bednar

Recent Trends:

  • Averaging 4.3 runs per game over last 10
  • Team ERA last 10 games: 4.61
  • Pirates have alternated wins and losses for eight straight games

St. Louis Cardinals (28–20)

Last 10: 7–3 Home Record: 15–9 Run Differential: +22 Team Identity:

  • Veteran core with strong situational hitting
  • Deep rotation
  • Reliable bullpen despite Helsley’s absence

Recent Trends:

  • Averaging 4.9 runs per game over last 10
  • Team ERA last 10 games: 3.72
  • Cardinals have won three straight series

Key Player Matchups

1. Oneil Cruz (PIT) vs. Logan May (STL)

  • Cruz’s elite bat speed vs. May’s heavy sinker.
  • May induces ground balls at a 54% rate, ideal for neutralizing power hitters.
  • Cruz struggles vs. low‑in‑zone sinkers.

Edge: May, if he keeps the ball down.

2. Bryan Reynolds (PIT) vs. Cardinals Bullpen

  • Reynolds is hitting .333 over his last 10 games.
  • St. Louis’ bullpen ERA vs. LHB is 3.41, one of the best in the NL.
  • Reynolds must produce early before late‑inning matchups tighten.

Edge: St. Louis, innings 7–9.

3. Paul Goldschmidt (STL) vs. Brandon Ashcraft (PIT)

  • Goldschmidt owns a career .310 average vs. power sinker/slider pitchers.
  • Ashcraft’s command issues (1.38 WHIP) make him vulnerable to veteran hitters.
  • Goldschmidt thrives at Busch Stadium in warm weather.

Edge: Goldschmidt, especially with runners on.

4. Nolan Arenado (STL) vs. Pirates Pitching

  • Arenado’s pull power plays well with wind blowing in from right‑center.
  • Pirates’ bullpen struggles vs. RHB (4.82 ERA).
  • Arenado is heating up: 3 HR in last 7 games.

Edge: Arenado, particularly late.

Series History

  • 2025 Season: Cardinals won series 10–9
  • Last 20 meetings: St. Louis leads 12–8
  • At Busch Stadium: Cardinals have won 8 of last 11

Trend: St. Louis consistently outperforms Pittsburgh at home, especially in close games.

Starting Pitching Breakdown

Brandon Ashcraft — RHP, Pittsburgh Pirates

2026 Season:

  • Record: 3–4
  • ERA: 4.52
  • WHIP: 1.38
  • K/BB: 42/18
  • HR Allowed: 6

Pitch Mix:

  • Sinker: 96 mph
  • Slider: 87 mph
  • Cutter: 92 mph
  • Changeup: 84 mph

Scouting Notes:

  • Generates weak contact when sinker is located
  • Struggles vs. disciplined lineups
  • High pitch counts limit his outings

Logan May — RHP, St. Louis Cardinals

2026 Season:

  • Record: 4–2
  • ERA: 3.41
  • WHIP: 1.19
  • K/BB: 51/14
  • HR Allowed: 5

Pitch Mix:

  • Sinker: 94 mph
  • Curveball: 79 mph
  • Slider: 85 mph
  • Changeup: 82 mph

Scouting Notes:

  • Excellent command
  • Ground‑ball specialist
  • Effective vs. both LHB and RHB

Betting Trends

Against the Spread (Run Line)

  • Pirates: 24–25 RL
  • Cardinals: 26–22 RL
  • Cardinals are 14–10 RL at home

Totals (O/U)

  • Pirates: 27–22 to the Over
  • Cardinals: 24–24 to the Over
  • Busch Stadium: Slight Under park

Situational Trends

  • Cardinals are 8–2 in last 10 home games
  • Pirates are 3–7 in last 10 road games vs. winning teams
  • May Overs have hit in 4 of last 6 starts

GAME ODDS

Pittsburgh Pirates            – 120

St. Louis Cardinals           7

Odds Courtesy of Sports Odds Direct as of Wednesday, May 20, 2026

Previous articleMLB Game Preview: Cleveland Guardians (29-22) vs. Detroit Tigers (20-30)
Next articleMLB Game Preview: New York Mets (21-28) vs. Washington Nationals (25-25)
MLB Editor
Profile: A dedicated Major League Baseball analyst with a comprehensive understanding of the sport’s strategic, statistical, and developmental layers. This columnist delivers in‑depth coverage that blends advanced metrics, scouting insight, and historical context to illuminate the trends shaping today’s game. Background: With extensive experience following MLB at both the team and league levels, the columnist has contributed to national sports outlets, digital platforms, and radio segments focused on roster construction, player evaluation, and organizational philosophy. A background in sports journalism and analytics supports a disciplined approach to breaking down performance, interpreting data, and tracking long‑term competitive cycles. Signature Coverage Areas: Game previews and pitching‑matchup analysis Advanced statistical breakdowns and sabermetric insights Prospect evaluation, farm‑system trends, and player development Trade‑deadline movement, free‑agency analysis, and front‑office strategy Historical context and postseason features Style & Approach: The writing emphasizes clarity, accuracy, and accessibility — translating complex data and tactical nuance into insights that resonate with both traditional fans and analytically minded readers. Each column reflects a commitment to balanced reporting, thoughtful evaluation, and a deep appreciation for the evolving landscape of Major League Baseball.