MLB Game Preview: Pittsburgh Pirates (25-24) vs. St. Louis Cardinals (28-20)

0
7
St. Louis Cardinals logo

First Pitch: 7:45 PM ET / 6:45 PM CT

Venue: Busch Stadium — St. Louis, Missouri

Broadcast: SportsNet Pittsburgh / Bally Sports Midwest / MLB.TV

Venue Profile — Busch Stadium

  • Location: Downtown St. Louis
  • Capacity: ~45,500
  • Park Factor: Slightly pitcher‑friendly
  • Home Run Profile: Suppresses opposite‑field power; neutral to pull power
  • Run Environment: Moderate scoring, heavily influenced by humidity and wind

Busch Stadium rewards ground‑ball pitchers and contact‑oriented offenses, which plays into St. Louis’ strengths.

Weather Update (Forecast for First Pitch)

  • Temperature: 78–81°F
  • Wind: 6–9 mph blowing in from right‑center
  • Humidity: ~62%
  • Chance of Rain: <10%
  • Impact: Slight suppression of fly‑ball carry; advantage to pitchers

Injury Report

Pittsburgh Pirates

  • Oneil Cruz — Probable (ankle)
  • Ke’Bryan Hayes — Out (back)
  • Henry Davis — Questionable (hand)
  • David Bednar — Out (forearm)
  • Marco Gonzales — Out (elbow)

St. Louis Cardinals

  • Paul Goldschmidt — Probable (hamstring)
  • Nolan Arenado — Probable (wrist)
  • Tommy Edman — Out (shoulder)
  • Ryan Helsley — Out (lat strain)
  • Lars Nootbaar — Questionable (illness)

Impact:

  • Pittsburgh’s bullpen is weakened without Bednar, making late‑inning leads fragile.
  • St. Louis missing Edman hurts defensive versatility, but Goldschmidt and Arenado being active stabilizes the lineup.
  • Both teams enter with key players banged up, but St. Louis’ depth is stronger.

Team Records & Recent Form

Pittsburgh Pirates (25–24)

Last 10: 5–5 Road Record: 12–13 Run Differential: –4 Team Identity:

  • Young, aggressive lineup
  • Inconsistent starting pitching
  • Bullpen volatility without Bednar

Recent Trends:

  • Averaging 4.3 runs per game over last 10
  • Team ERA last 10 games: 4.61
  • Pirates have alternated wins and losses for eight straight games

St. Louis Cardinals (28–20)

Last 10: 7–3 Home Record: 15–9 Run Differential: +22 Team Identity:

  • Veteran core with strong situational hitting
  • Deep rotation
  • Reliable bullpen despite Helsley’s absence

Recent Trends:

  • Averaging 4.9 runs per game over last 10
  • Team ERA last 10 games: 3.72
  • Cardinals have won three straight series

Key Player Matchups

1. Oneil Cruz (PIT) vs. Logan May (STL)

  • Cruz’s elite bat speed vs. May’s heavy sinker.
  • May induces ground balls at a 54% rate, ideal for neutralizing power hitters.
  • Cruz struggles vs. low‑in‑zone sinkers.

Edge: May, if he keeps the ball down.

2. Bryan Reynolds (PIT) vs. Cardinals Bullpen

  • Reynolds is hitting .333 over his last 10 games.
  • St. Louis’ bullpen ERA vs. LHB is 3.41, one of the best in the NL.
  • Reynolds must produce early before late‑inning matchups tighten.

Edge: St. Louis, innings 7–9.

3. Paul Goldschmidt (STL) vs. Brandon Ashcraft (PIT)

  • Goldschmidt owns a career .310 average vs. power sinker/slider pitchers.
  • Ashcraft’s command issues (1.38 WHIP) make him vulnerable to veteran hitters.
  • Goldschmidt thrives at Busch Stadium in warm weather.

Edge: Goldschmidt, especially with runners on.

4. Nolan Arenado (STL) vs. Pirates Pitching

  • Arenado’s pull power plays well with wind blowing in from right‑center.
  • Pirates’ bullpen struggles vs. RHB (4.82 ERA).
  • Arenado is heating up: 3 HR in last 7 games.

Edge: Arenado, particularly late.

Series History

  • 2025 Season: Cardinals won series 10–9
  • Last 20 meetings: St. Louis leads 12–8
  • At Busch Stadium: Cardinals have won 8 of last 11

Trend: St. Louis consistently outperforms Pittsburgh at home, especially in close games.

Starting Pitching Breakdown

Brandon Ashcraft — RHP, Pittsburgh Pirates

2026 Season:

  • Record: 3–4
  • ERA: 4.52
  • WHIP: 1.38
  • K/BB: 42/18
  • HR Allowed: 6

Pitch Mix:

  • Sinker: 96 mph
  • Slider: 87 mph
  • Cutter: 92 mph
  • Changeup: 84 mph

Scouting Notes:

  • Generates weak contact when sinker is located
  • Struggles vs. disciplined lineups
  • High pitch counts limit his outings

Logan May — RHP, St. Louis Cardinals

2026 Season:

  • Record: 4–2
  • ERA: 3.41
  • WHIP: 1.19
  • K/BB: 51/14
  • HR Allowed: 5

Pitch Mix:

  • Sinker: 94 mph
  • Curveball: 79 mph
  • Slider: 85 mph
  • Changeup: 82 mph

Scouting Notes:

  • Excellent command
  • Ground‑ball specialist
  • Effective vs. both LHB and RHB

Betting Trends

Against the Spread (Run Line)

  • Pirates: 24–25 RL
  • Cardinals: 26–22 RL
  • Cardinals are 14–10 RL at home

Totals (O/U)

  • Pirates: 27–22 to the Over
  • Cardinals: 24–24 to the Over
  • Busch Stadium: Slight Under park

Situational Trends

  • Cardinals are 8–2 in last 10 home games
  • Pirates are 3–7 in last 10 road games vs. winning teams
  • May Overs have hit in 4 of last 6 starts

GAME ODDS

Pittsburgh Pirates            – 120

St. Louis Cardinals           7

Odds Courtesy of Sports Odds Direct as of Wednesday, May 20, 2026