NAIA-CFB Game Preview: Mayville State Comets (1-1) vs. Simpson (CA) Red Hawks (0-2)

0
38

Venue & Logistics

  • Venue: Bill Johnson Community Stadium, Redding, California (home of Simpson University Red Hawks)
  • Kickoff Time: 7:00 PM PDT (9:00 PM CDT)
  • Broadcast: Simpson Athletics Live Stream, Frontier Conference Network

Weather Forecast (Redding, CA)

  • Conditions: Clear skies, warm evening
  • Temperature: 88°F (31°C) at kickoff, cooling to 76°F (24°C) by the fourth quarter
  • Winds: 6–9 mph from the northwest
  • Precipitation:
  • Impact: Classic Northern California late-summer weather; heat could test depth, especially for Mayville State traveling west

Injury Report

  • Mayville State Comets:
    • QB1 (shoulder soreness) – Probable
    • RB2 (ankle) – Questionable
    • LB1 (hamstring) – Out
  • Simpson Red Hawks:
  • QB1 (wrist) – Probable
  • WR2 (groin) – Game-time decision
  • DB1 (concussion protocol) – Out

Key Player Matchups

  • QB1 (Mayville State) vs. Simpson Secondary – The Comets’ passing game has been inconsistent; Simpson’s DBs must capitalize on turnover chances.
  • RB Committee (Simpson) vs. Mayville State Front Seven – Simpson’s ground game is their offensive anchor; Mayville must control the line of scrimmage.
  • WR1 (Mayville State) vs. Simpson Corners – With WR2 questionable, WR1 will be the focal point; Simpson must double him to avoid explosive plays.
  • Special Teams: Both squads have shown inconsistency in the kicking game; field position could be decisive.

Recent Team Form

  • Mayville State Comets:
    • W vs. Judson (Ill.) 49-20 (Aug. 28)
    • L at Concordia (Minn.) 17-6 (Sep. 6)
    • Balanced start; offense averaging 27.5 points per game, defense allowing 18.5.
  • Simpson Red Hawks:
  • L vs. Southern Oregon 59-0 (Aug. 28)
  • L at Eastern Oregon 41-10 (Sep. 6)
  • Struggling on both sides; offense averaging 5 points per game, defense allowing 50.

Series History

  • All-Time Meetings: First official meeting between Mayville State and Simpson (CA)
  • Context: Mayville State is in its second season as a Frontier affiliate; Simpson is still building its NAIA program.

Betting Trends

  • Mayville State is 4-2 ATS in its last 6 non-conference games.
  • Simpson is 1-7 ATS in its last 8 overall.
  • The Under has hit in 4 of Mayville’s last 6 road games.
  • Simpson is 0-5 straight up in its last 5 vs. Frontier opponents.

Historical Betting Results

  • 2024 (Mayville State): Lost 28-14 vs. Dickinson State → No Cover, Under
  • 2024 (Simpson): Lost 42-7 vs. College of Idaho → No Cover, Under
  • 2023 (Simpson): Lost 35-10 vs. Montana Tech → No Cover, Under

Game Odds

Mayville State Comets                   – 10.5

Simpson (CA) Red Hawks              48

Odds Courtesy of Sports Odd Direct as of Friday, September 19, 2025